Get Joy vs NaturVet Quiet Moments: What You Get at Each Price

Updated: July 2026 · Reviewed by the Get Joy veterinary and nutrition team · See our vet & nutrition experts

NaturVet Quiet Moments and Get Joy Calming Chews sit at different ends of the calming aisle, and each is honest about what it is. Quiet Moments is a sensible, established, budget-friendly formula, pairing melatonin for situational effect with thiamine, L-tryptophan, chamomile, and ginger, NASC certified, at one of the lowest costs per chew in the category. Get Joy Calming Chews cost more and are built differently: a melatonin-free, hemp-free daily botanical formula on a gut-first foundation. If you need calming support a handful of times a year and price is the deciding factor, Quiet Moments is a fair value; if you are feeding for the everyday, Get Joy is built for that.

The real question is not which is cheaper per chew. It is whether you are buying for a few hard days a year or for every day, because that changes what the right math even is.

What is the main difference between Get Joy and NaturVet Quiet Moments?

The main difference is what each is designed to do: Quiet Moments is a melatonin-led event chew for occasional stress, while Get Joy is a hormone-free daily botanical built to support the baseline. That difference in purpose is bigger than the difference in price.

Quiet Moments delivers real value for a few hard days a year. But feed an event chew daily, indefinitely, and you are asking a situational tool to do a wellness job it was never built for. Get Joy is built for the dog whose stress is a baseline, the daily pacing, the doorbell reactivity, the loose stool every time the routine shifts, and it starts below the behavior with gut support at every meal.

How do Get Joy and Quiet Moments compare at a glance?

Here is the head-to-head on the factors dog parents ask about most.

What is in each chew, and how does it work?

The two formulas overlap only on chamomile and diverge sharply on melatonin, which is the ingredient that defines how Quiet Moments is meant to be used. Here is the honest breakdown.

Quiet Moments pairs melatonin, the hormone at the center of the formula, effective for situational events and generally suggested for occasional rather than daily use, with L-tryptophan, an amino acid precursor involved in mood-related signaling, and thiamine, vitamin B1, which supports healthy nervous system function. Ginger is a quietly smart inclusion for travel because it supports digestive comfort during car rides, and chamomile promotes relaxation while supporting digestive comfort. The NASC quality seal signals audited manufacturing standards, which is not a given at this price tier.

Get Joy keeps chamomile and builds around it with valerian root, a traditional nervous system calming botanical, passion flower, which supports relaxation and emotional balance, and omega-3 from algae, which supports brain health and a normal inflammatory response. No melatonin, no hemp, no hormones, nothing designed to sedate. The chews are vet-formulated, developed with PhD animal nutritionists, grain-free, and made in the USA. For more on why the melatonin question matters in a daily chew, see our guide to L-theanine vs melatonin for dogs.

Are cheap calming chews as good as premium ones?

For occasional use, an established budget brand like NaturVet does the job at excellent value; for daily use, formulation matters more than price-per-chew. That is the honest answer, and it depends entirely on how often you feed.

Price-per-chew is the right math for a handful of events a year. For daily feeding, the better math is what you are actually putting in your dog every day: hormone-free actives suited to everyday use, sourcing consistency, and whether anything supports the underlying gut-brain baseline. That is what the price difference buys with Get Joy: premium sourcing, a formula built for daily feeding, and a system underneath it. Both brands are NASC certified, which is a genuine mark of audited manufacturing standards; if you want to know exactly what that seal means, read what NASC certification means for dog supplements.

Which fits real life: travel, storms, and separation?

Match the tool to the calendar: for storms, the Fourth of July, or a road trip a few times a year, Quiet Moments does the occasional job affordably; for daily or near-daily stress, a hormone-free daily chew on a gut-first foundation fits better. Both have a place.

The ginger in Quiet Moments is a thoughtful touch for travel specifically. If your dog is relaxed most of the time and only struggles during specific events, an affordable situational chew is a reasonable thing to keep on hand. If instead the stress is daily, or it shows up in the gut as loose stool during disruption, appetite swings, or restless licking, that pattern points to supporting the baseline rather than dosing each event. Get Joy Calming Chews are built to support calm every day, including through travel, storms, and time apart, as part of a steady routine. For the separation piece, see our guide to dog separation stress signs and solutions, and for gentle at-home ideas, natural calming remedies for dogs at home.

Why does gut health matter for a calm dog?

Gut health matters because the gut-brain axis means your dog's stress response is shaped at every meal: much of the body's mood-related signaling originates in the gut, and a supported microbiome underpins a healthy baseline. This is the layer a budget event chew does not address.

Get Joy freeze-dried raw meals are built on Belly Biotics™, our proprietary blend of prebiotics, probiotics, and postbiotics, built directly into the food. The chew supports the day; the food supports the baseline. Together they cover both. You can read the full science in our pillar on the dog gut-brain axis and behavior.

The verdict: Get Joy or NaturVet Quiet Moments?

Quiet Moments is honest value for a few hard days a year; Get Joy is an investment in all the other days. There is no shame in the budget pick for the occasional job, as long as occasional is really what you are solving for.

Frequently asked questions

Is Get Joy a good alternative to NaturVet Quiet Moments?

For daily use, yes. Get Joy Calming Chews are melatonin-free, hemp-free botanicals formulated for everyday feeding, backed by gut-healthy meals supporting the gut-brain axis. Quiet Moments remains a fair budget option for genuinely occasional situational events.

Does NaturVet Quiet Moments contain melatonin?

Yes, melatonin leads the formula alongside thiamine, L-tryptophan, chamomile, and ginger. That composition suits occasional events like storms and travel, and is less appropriate as an indefinite daily supplement, since melatonin is a hormone generally positioned for situational use.

Are cheap calming chews as good as premium ones?

For occasional use, an established budget brand like NaturVet does the job at excellent value. For daily use, formulation matters more: hormone-free actives suited to everyday feeding, sourcing consistency, and whether anything supports the underlying gut-brain baseline.

Can I give calming chews daily?

Get Joy Calming Chews are formulated for daily use at label dosing, with no hormones. Melatonin-led budget chews are better kept for situational moments. Whatever you feed, follow the label and consult your vet if your dog takes medication or has a health condition.

How long do calming supplements take to work?

Situational melatonin chews work within about an hour for single events. Daily botanical formulas show effects within days to two weeks of consistency. Gut-level nutritional support builds over four to six weeks, which is where lasting baseline improvement comes from.

Competitor details (active panels, melatonin use, format, pricing tier) are drawn from each brand's own website and public retailer listings (Chewy, Petco, Amazon) as of July 2026; prices and formulas can change, so confirm current details on each brand's site. Get Joy figures are from getjoyfood.com and internal product documentation. Get Joy Calming Chews are intended to support everyday calm and relaxation and are not a substitute for veterinary care; consult your veterinarian for persistent or severe stress behaviors.