Get Joy vs Stewart's Freeze-Dried Liver Treats: A Trainer's Comparison

Updated: July 2026 · Reviewed against verified competitor data and Get Joy product facts · See our vet & nutrition experts

Stewart's and Get Joy both make single ingredient, freeze-dried raw beef liver treats in the USA, and both are genuinely good, so this comparison is not about which brand is legitimate. Stewart's is the category original, with roughly fifty years of history and a classic training-tub format, while Get Joy is the modern take: three beef organs instead of one, built into a complete gut-first nutrition routine spanning meals, treats, and supplements. That means Stewart's suits the trainer who wants the proven high-volume tub, and Get Joy suits the parent who wants organ variety and a full routine behind the treat.

If your trainer recommended Stewart's, they gave you good advice, and this article is not here to change that. It is here to show where the two brands are identical, where they diverge, and how to decide which one belongs in your treat pouch.

What is the difference between Get Joy and Stewart's liver treats?

Both are single ingredient freeze-dried raw beef liver made in the USA; the difference is that Get Joy adds beef heart and kidney options and connects the treat to a full gut-first routine, while Stewart's focuses on the classic liver training tub. Stewart's practically invented this aisle. Their freeze-dried beef liver is made with one simple ingredient, 100% beef liver, grain free and gluten free with no artificial flavoring or fillers, made in small batches in the USA, and the brand has been at it for more than forty-five years. The tubs are a trainer favorite for a reason: a 21oz tub holds roughly 475 pieces at about 50% protein, which is a lot of reps per container.

Get Joy takes the same single ingredient standard and builds outward. The Superfood line covers three beef organs, and the treat shares a brand, a philosophy, and a freeze-dried raw standard with the Freeze-Dried Raw Meal in the bowl, the Belly Biotics gut support inside that meal, and the supplements that round out the day. Stewart's ends at the treat. Get Joy starts there.

Get Joy vs Stewart's at a glance

Here is the head-to-head on the factors dog parents ask about most.

What is inside each treat?

The ingredient panels are even: Get Joy Superfood Beef Liver lists Beef Liver, and Stewart's Pro-Treat Beef Liver lists Beef Liver. So the comparison moves to what each brand builds around that ingredient.

Organ variety

Stewart's beef line is liver-led. Get Joy offers liver, heart, and kidney, letting you rotate nutrient profiles without ever leaving beef: vitamin A and iron from liver, taurine and CoQ10 naturally present in heart, and B vitamins and selenium from kidney. For dogs on limited diets, that is variety without risk. Our guide to beef liver, heart, and kidney for dogs breaks down each organ.

The routine behind the treat

Stewart's makes very good treats and toppers. Get Joy builds a full daily system: Freeze-Dried Raw Meals with Belly Biotics for gut support, Superfood Treats for training and rewards, and supplements to round out the routine. One brand, one quality standard, one philosophy that gut health drives whole-body health. When your treat and your meal come from the same system, you never wonder whether one is working against the other.

Can dogs with chicken sensitivities eat these treats?

Yes, both are 100% beef with no poultry ingredients, making either a practical pick for dogs avoiding chicken. Chicken is one of the most commonly reported food sensitivities in dogs, and it often hides in beef-flavored treats as chicken meal or chicken fat, so a true single ingredient beef treat removes the guesswork. Confirm with your veterinarian if your dog has a diagnosed allergy.

Which is the better training treat?

Both are proven training treats, and the pick comes down to format and variety. Freeze-dried beef liver is high in protein, low in calories per piece, intensely aromatic, and easy to break into small rewards, which is why trainers have relied on it for decades. Stewart's tubs are built for volume training at home, with a high piece count per container. Get Joy's bags are built for the couch, the trail, and the jacket pocket, and the liver, heart, and kidney rotation keeps a dog engaged across long sessions. Neither is wrong; you can even decant a tub into a pouch and call it even. Whichever you use, follow the 10% rule: keep total treats to no more than about 10% of your dog's daily calories, and because organ meat is nutrient-rich, especially liver with its vitamin A content, break treats into smaller pieces on heavy training days so the reward count stays high while calories stay controlled.

The verdict: Get Joy or Stewart's?

Stewart's earned its shelf space over five decades and the product still holds up. Get Joy is what we believe the next fifty years of this category looks like: the same single ingredient integrity, more organ variety, and a treat that plugs into a complete routine instead of standing alone. Respect the original. Feed the upgrade.

Frequently asked questions

Is freeze-dried beef liver a good training treat?

Yes. Freeze-dried beef liver is high in protein, low in calories per piece, intensely aromatic, and easy to break into small rewards, which is why trainers have relied on it for decades. Keep total treats to no more than about 10% of your dog's daily calories.

Are organ meat treats good for dogs?

Yes. Organ meats are among the most nutrient-dense whole foods a dog can eat, naturally rich in vitamin A, B vitamins, iron, and amino acids. Feed them in moderation as treats rather than meals, and keep treats under about 10% of daily calories.

What is the difference between Get Joy and Stewart's liver treats?

Both are single ingredient freeze-dried raw beef liver made in the USA. Get Joy adds beef heart and kidney options and connects the treat to a full gut-first routine of meals and supplements, while Stewart's focuses on the classic liver training tub.

Can dogs with chicken sensitivities eat these treats?

Yes. Both are 100% beef with no poultry ingredients, making either a practical pick for dogs avoiding chicken. Confirm with your veterinarian if your dog has a diagnosed allergy.

How many freeze-dried liver treats can I give my dog per day?

Follow the 10% rule: treats should be no more than about 10% of daily calories. For a low-calorie freeze-dried liver piece, that may mean a handful for a small dog and more for a large dog. Check your bag's calorie content and your dog's needs.

Competitor details (ingredients, protein, piece count, sizes) are drawn from Stewart's own product pages and public retailer listings as of July 2026; prices and specs can change, so confirm current details on each brand's site. Get Joy figures are from getjoyfood.com and internal product documentation. This article is for education and is not veterinary advice; consult your veterinarian for your dog's individual needs, especially for diagnosed allergies. Learn more from the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO).